U.K. Advertising Standards Authority Takes Stand Against Airbrushing

I recently wrote an article about airbrushing in the media and the unhealthy body image such doctored pictures promote for women.  Now the U.K’s Advertising Standards Authority has taken a hardline, banning  product ads of Julia Roberts for Lancome and Christy Turlington for Maybeline (both companies falling under the umbrella of L’Oreal). Check out the ads here, along with L’Oreal’s “justifications.”  Member of Parliament Jo Swinson stated that the “adverts were not representative of the results the products could achieve.”  In addition to L’Oreal’s mispresenting of the products, Swinson expressed her concern that such ads could lead to body image problems.

Entertainment Weekly did obtain a telling comment from Sharon A. Blinkoff, an attorney with Venable LLP who’s represented clients in the cosmetic industry for more than 20 years and sits on the board of directors of the Independent Cosmetics Manufacturers Association, giving her opinion that the United States Trade Commission wouldn’t have granted similar consumer protection:

“Under U.S. law, the question becomes whether a consumer acting reasonably would be in some way misled and believe that the product would do things that it doesn’t in fact do. I think consumers are used to cosmetic companies taking some creative license with their presentation and generally know what foundation products do and what they don’t do. Our regulatory agencies recognize the ‘sophistication’ of the American consumer…There’s also the notion that these are not very high-ticket items: consumers can judge for themselves whether they’re satisfied, and if they’re not satisfied, they won’t buy it again…. Even the lighting that you use when you take a photo of a model will sometimes change the appearance. Are we now gonna say everybody has to be put under standard lighting, so that we make sure that there’s no deviation? Instead of having beauty shots, we’ll have mug shots. Consumers like the aspirational characteristics of these photographs. They know that they’re not gonna become a Julia Roberts.” Continue reading

Should Women Add Liposuction and Cosmetic Surgery to Their Beauty Regimes?

Liposuction and Cosmetic Surgery on the Rise

In a recent women’s magazine article, liposuction is presented as a procedure that we as women should respect as a woman’s choice to do what she wants with her body. The author is a staunch advocate in favor of liposuction. I believe strongly in personal autonomy and not judging others. But I think it is taking it too far to suggest that women “poohing-poohing the idea of not embracing the idea of paying to have their fat sucked out of a tube should stop combing their hair and washing their face.”

Here I’ve been stockpiling makeup from Sephora, dieting and working out. Little did I know all I needed to do was have an elective cosmetic procedure where they knocked me out and vacuumed out those pesky fat cells. Damn that daily beauty regime. I could have just slept in.

cosmetic surgery article was published by the magazine in February 2009. The article talked about how women are feeling increasingly pressured to look like their younger counterparts to compete in the bad economy and tightening workplace. And these women aren’t senior citizens.  Instead, women who want to look younger and fresher are in their 30′s and 40′s are seeking anti-injectibles and the suctioning of neck fat (to make a more angular chin) to avoid looking run down when “walk[ing] into a room full of fetuses.”

As a whole, women are feeling like we need to look thinner, younger, more perfect. Where do we draw the line?

How Lipo Works

Liposuction is meant for people with healthy lifestyles who have fat deposits on their bodies that are resistant to dieting and exercise. The lipo “shocker” referred to in the June 2011 article is that liposuction does not mean you won’t gain weight. Your doctor is sucking out resistant deposits of fat from body areas where diet and exercise haven’t yielded results. Fat elsewhere in your body remains. Lipo is meant to contour particular body parts, rather than be used as a weight loss device at large.

A Lipo Veteran

The author of the June 2011 article has had lipo twice. The first time she had her fat sucked out of of her hips and thighs she gained it back in her stomach “badly and unevenly with minor nerve damage that lasted for years.”

Fortunately, the author didn’t wasn’t one of the few undergoing surgery who in her words becomes “the moron who winds up dead because [she] wanted to wear skinny jeans.”

Next, the author had a tummy tuck and and lipo post-pregnancy.  Though she gained weight, to her relief her weight was more evenly distributed.

Eventually though, the author bemoaned the return of fat in non-lipo’ed areas of her body. This time, she resigned herself to “the tedious process of diet and exercise (ultimately more expensive than lipo, since [she] seem[s] incapable of physical exertion without some buff dude standing over [her], barking orders).”

You know, the tedious process so many of us struggle with. Unfortunately mostly minus the yummy buff dude, which could be fun if you’re into that sort of thing (apologies to my wonderful husband Ted). And committing to the not-always-fun healthy diet that surgeons recommend post-surgery in order to maintain optimal results before using liposuction as a last resort.  You need to keep up that diet before and liposuction.  You need to keep up that diet whether or not you have surgery.  There’s no quick and easy escape. Continue reading

Pro-Anorexia Blogs and Body Positive Blogs: Equating The Two is Simply Idiotic

Are body positive photo blogs actually positive? Websites and blogs such as Refinery 29 and iVillage have been abuzz about this issue. Here’s a picture from Curve Appeal, a body-positive blog that allows readers of all shapes and sizes to post pictures of themselves  to celebrate their beauty, showing what “real women” look like, with all of their non-airbrushed curves:

The young woman in the picture comments on her photo as follows:

I’m Kayla, I’m 5’6” and I’m a size 12-14 US. It wasn’t until a year after graduating high school that I realized I’m never going to be a size 4 and honestly, I couldn’t be love my curves more. They make me feel unique and beautiful. I love my hips, butt, and legs. I choose not to weigh myself because I don’t want to know. I wear what I think looks good on me and that’s all I care about.

Here’s another photo from Stop Hating Your Body:

The 18 year old woman in the picture has this to say:

Ever since i got into Middle school i could never accept my body. either i was too fat or what not. I used to be made fun of for my weight, and i struggled a lot with it. I didn’t like wearing bikinis, i didn’t like eating in front of people, i was just embarrassed about my body. I could never accept it till now. I just graduated high school, and when i look at myself in the mirror i see a beautiful person. I mean i am a little curvy, but i accept it now. Many years of fighting my body image, i now realize that my body is beautiful, and i am a strong person. No one can bring me down. I love the way i am. At one point i thought no guys would love me cause the way i look. but guys tell me my body is sexy. and they love it. I was so afraid of myself that i didn’t open up to guys, so i basically blamed them for something i was doing to myself. I LOVE WHO I AM. i am beautiful inside and out. No one is going to change me. respect your body. be healthy and love who you are. If you love yourself and let go of all the negative, then you can accept yourself.

I’m touched and inspired by these womens’ words. I applaud their bravery and willingness to open themselves up, show what they’ve been through and where they are now. Realizing you are struggling with the same issues as others have worked or are working through can make you feel less alone. When I had an eating disorder, part of my treatment was group therapy. Sharing our stories and encouraging each other was a pivotal part of my recovery. Continue reading

Photoshopping: Acceptable Art or Promotion of Unhealthy Body Images?

The media has been buzzing lately about the AMA’s new policy speaking out against advertiser’s heavily photoshopped images that distort model’s body images.  I believe (as does the AMA) that young girls see these unrealistic images and believe these models are something to aspire towards.  The AMA has stated that these pictures contribute to eating disorders and other health problems in children and adolescents.  Likewise, The Girl Scouts are launching a campaign called Healthy MEdia: Commission for Positive Images of Women and Girls to work with media leaders to address this issue.

I read an article in the Huffington Post today discussing in part a French proposal to require the publishers of enhanced images to provide a warning label or risk fines.  Photographers on the other hand say that their artistic freedom should not be hindered for any reason.

As a writer, I’m all for artistic freedom. But I think that passing off these images of women as being the real thing and normal and healthy is irresponsible. There is a line between art and commerce, and how the image is being used and represented.  When I’m writing fiction, I’m not trying to pass it off as nonfiction (I’ll leave that to James Frey).  I do think it could be a fine line to regulate.  What’s artistic vision and what’s straight-up misleading?  What’s fixing a blemish and what’s turning someone into a head on a stick? Continue reading

Walking: Why I Decided to Lose Weight

I’ve always been a fast walker. Stereotypical New Yorker, striding straight ahead, looking straight ahead, weaving and passing people. Slow down, my mom and my friend Betsy would both tell me.

Until my knee started to give out on me. Every couple of months, it would begin to hurt. Then it would lock and buckle. I’d jerk and feel like I was going to fall. Then I’d try to keep my knee stiff and keep walking, hoping it wouldn’t happen again.

I tried to ignore it. It was only once in a while, I reasoned. Then I slipped in the bathroom at work, twisted my leg and fell. After that, my knee problem turned into a constant problem. More days than not, my knee buckled or at least hurt.

Going anywhere became a problem. I’d have to look for a chair to sit and take a break when shopping. I started taking cabs. I stopped wanting to go anywhere.

I walked to and from the train station every day to get to work. I’d walk slowly and I could feel the other commuters walking on the sidewalk behind me, getting closer, and I’d try to quicken my pace. And then they’d pass me.

I dreaded stairs. I took a writing class in a classroom on the third floor of a building. No elevator. The first class, I walked up with a classmate, and was so out of breath I could barely speak to my instructor and classmates.  I was mortified. After that, I was sure to get there early, to take things at my own pace. That way, no one would catch me stopping between flights, reaching for my inhaler.

One day I got fed up. Took the day off from work and went to a medical clinic.  They did an x-ray but didn’t find anything. They referred me to their practice’s orthopedist.

The orthopedist took a look at my x-ray. He told me I had a loss of cartilage in my knee. Bone spurs. Osteoarthritis. He told me he would have thought the x-ray was that of a fifty-something year old woman, who would eventually need knee replacement surgery. I asked him what could be done about it. He told me nothing would fix it, but that losing weight would relieve the symptoms.

I went out to the parking lot, sat in my car and cried. I had waited too long to lose weight. I had ruined my knee and it couldn’t be fixed. My mother had more minor knee problems in her thirties but didn’t need knee surgery until she was over 60. Continue reading

Curvy Models’ New Body-Friendly Business

I had the pleasure of meeting Shannon Hiett and Griselangel Paula, two smart and dynamic plus size models at the 2011 Full Figured Fashion Week’s Curves in the City Shopping Soiree. Shannon and Griselangel have combined their business acumen with their dedication to create CustomPLUS, an online customized clothing company.

Shannon Hiett and Griselangel Paula

Shannon has been involved in the plus community for three years as a fit model, informal model and print model with various clients, including Destination Maternity, David’s Bridal, Macy’s, Bloomingdale’s, Daphne Larger Sizes, SwimsuitsForAll.com, Tru Diva Designs, and many more.

Shannon met Griselangel during Queens Fashion Week and a fast friendship formed. Griselangel has modeled for numerous companies and designers such as Kmart, Plus Model Magazine, Rocawear, Baby Phat, Beyonce’s House of Dereon, Biflex and Applebottoms amongst many others. Griselangel is represented internationally throughout Africa, and North America.

The Figure-Flattering Clothes of CustomPLUS

Shannon and Griselangel created CustomPLUS in early 2011 after discussing their frustration with the lack of customizable plus size garments that didn’t cost more than straight size garments. They also wanted to create a business that coincided with their passion for the plus size industry. Because they are fuller figured women, they know how garments should fit and that style is a must. CustomPLUS garments are of substantial quality, figure flattering and can be worn daily!

CustomPLUS-A Fair and Forwarding-Thinking Business Model

The ingenuity of CustomPLUS is not simply its quality, well-made clothing with wide customization options. I was impressed by the equality in its(reasonable) pricing. As I have previously stated, a challenge and problem for plus size consumers is having to pay higher prices than straight size counterparts for the exact same clothing. At CustomPLUS, there is one price for each item, size notwithstanding. Continue reading

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 238 other followers

%d bloggers like this: